I do genuinely feel sorry for Ian Duncan Smith. Scouring the newspapers it is impossible to find a single article that has anything positive to say about him. Commentators in papers that support the Conservatives, like the Telegraph and Mail titles, are the most vicious.
I feel a natural pang of human sympathy for a man being universally kicked when already down.
The fact it is not his opponents, but members of his own party and the Tory press doing the kicking makes it even more unsightly.
It also diverts attention from the Conservatives� policy which is a shame. The received wisdom is that the Tories have been in a mess since they dumped Mrs Thatcher because they have had a succession of hopeless leaders. John Major, William Hague and IDS were all chosen by the party faithful because they were not Michael Heseltine, Ken Clarke or Michael Portillo.
This was no accident or a reflection of a perverse desire to lose on the part of Conservative members. It is simply that Major Hague and IDS better represented Thatcherism continued than there opponents.
The ditching of Mrs Thatcher and Labour�s two landslides were only partly about personality. Primarily they were about policy � a rejection of Thatcherism by the voters and a desire for a centre or a centre left alternative.
As long as most Tories still fail to recognise this they will continue to squabble about their leadership. IDS is not the problem, he is just a symptom.
The problem is his party�s continuing failure to understand why it lost power in 1997 and what it needs to do if it is to hold any hope of gaining it again.
|