I have every sympathy for the pensioners who lobbied me at Parliament last week
What struck me was that they did not bend my ear about pensions as such but used virtually the whole time we spent together complaining about the council tax.
Nobody likes paying tax. Nobody likes paying the council tax in particular. Most of us pay VAT every day without being aware of it. For most people, income tax is deducted automatically from their pay packet. The difference with council tax is that it pops through our letter boxes in the form of a bill which we notice having to pay.
Property tax is older than income tax. It is easy and cheap to collect and difficult to avoid.
In recent years it has gone to help pay for many local services like schools, social services, roads and leisure.
The common complaint is that it does not take account of one�s ability to pay.
To some extent this is true. But the least well off don�t pay it at all and people who live alone have a discount. While it doesn�t take account of income it does take account of capital wealth based on the value of one�s home.
The people who like it least tend to be single people or couples who live in valuable homes who resent paying the same as a working family of four next door.
That was the motivation behind Mrs Thatcher�s poll tax which abolished the property link and levied a flat rate tax on every adult.
That led to her downfall. So critics of the council tax have to think very carefully about how else they would raise money for local services.
Local income tax many sound superficially attractive, but experts say it would be horrendously complicated and expensive.
So making the council tax fairer while clamping down on local authorities that levy unreasonable increases seems the most likely way forward.
|